Liquid Cooling for Computer Chips: Solving the Heat Problem

Introduction: The “Thermal Wall” in AI Mass Production

AI and HPC advances have driven semiconductor power beyond 1000W, creating a “thermal wall.” Traditional cooling methods can’t match the heat flux from modern transistors.

Leading foundries like TSMC and Intel show Direct-to-Chip Liquid Cooling (DLC) as the solution. This requires architectural changes: CoWoS, SoIC, and Glass Substrates must evolve to enable heat dissipation while managing warpage. This article examines how advanced packaging is being re-engineered to bring coolant closer to silicon.

---

1. Heat Bottleneck in 2.5D and 3D Packaging

CoWoS and SoIC enable the chiplet era but introduce thermal resistance barriers.

1.1 CoWoS: The Interposer Challenge

In TSMC’s CoWoS, logic dies and HBM stacks sit on a silicon interposer.

• The Problem: The interposer adds thermal resistance. Large packages create non-uniform heat distribution, causing hotspots and throttling.
• The Constraint: Larger packages increase heat travel distance and mechanical stress.

1.2 SoIC: The 3D Density Trap

SoIC stacks dies vertically.

• Thermal Trapping: Creates a “thermal sandwich” where heat from bottom dies must escape through top dies or thermal pillars.
• Interface Resistance: Each bonding interface adds thermal resistance, risking reliability failures.

---

2. Direct-to-Chip Liquid Cooling: Lab to Fab

The industry moves toward Direct-to-Chip cooling to bypass lid and TIM thermal resistance.

2.1 Why “Direct” Matters

Traditional: Die → TIM1 → IHS → TIM2 → Cold Plate.

Direct cooling eliminates IHS and TIM2, bringing coolant to the die backside.

• Efficiency: Reduces thermal resistance over 40%, cooling chips exceeding 100W/cm².
• Mass Production: Major foundries show DLC moving from supercomputing to data centers. Supply chains for microfluidic cold plates are maturing.

2.2 Structural Adaptations

Integrating liquid channels requires packaging modifications.

• Microfluidic Interposers: Cooling channels integrated into silicon interposers, allowing coolant beneath logic dies.
• Lidless Packaging: Bare-die configurations need stiffener rings and precise handling to prevent cracking.

---

3. Glass Substrates: Foundation for Thermal and Mechanical Stability

As organic substrates reach limits, Glass Substrates emerge as transformative for advanced packaging.

3.1 Superior Thermal Conductivity

Glass offers adjustable thermal properties. Specialized compositions and Through-Glass Vias enable efficient heat conduction.

3.2 Solving Warpage

Warpage kills yield in large packages.

• CTE Mismatch: CTE differences between die, substrate, and motherboard cause warping during reflow.
• Glass Stability: Glass provides high stiffness and tunable CTE matching silicon, reducing warpage. Flat packages are crucial for DLC, ensuring uniform cold plate contact.

---

4. Warpage Control in DLC

Direct-to-Chip cooling demands strict mechanical requirements.

4.1 Flatness Requirement

Cold plates require tightly controlled package flatness.

• Gap Control: Micron-scale warp creates gaps, drastically increasing thermal resistance.
• Stiffener Rings: Metal or glass stiffener rings enforce planarity against cooling loop pressure.

4.2 High Pressure Handling

Cooling loops operate under pressure. Solder bumps must withstand cold plate compressive load without cracking over thermal cycles.

---

5. Future: Convergence of Cooling and Packaging

Packaging and thermal engineering are merging.

• Co-Design: Thermal simulation must be part of initial chiplet floor-planning.
• Integrated Micro-Cooling: Cooling structures fabricated during wafer process (e.g., TSMC’s on-chip water channels).

---

FAQ: Advanced Packaging & Liquid Cooling

Q1: What is the main advantage of Direct-to-Chip Liquid Cooling over immersion cooling?

A: DLC provides targeted heat removal for hottest components with less fluid and weight, easier to retrofit into existing racks.

Q2: How does SoIC affect thermal management versus CoWoS?

A: SoIC stacks chips vertically, increasing thermal density and resistance for bottom dies, requiring more aggressive cooling than CoWoS’s planar arrangement.

Q3: Why are Glass Substrates better for large AI chips?

A: Glass provides superior stability and tunable CTE, minimizing warpage in large packages. This flatness is critical for reliable interconnects and thermal contact.

---

Conclusion

Mass production of Direct-to-Chip Liquid Cooling is a physical necessity. As AI chips breach the “thermal wall,” packaging structures—CoWoS, SoIC, Glass Substrates—evolve to prioritize heat dissipation. Mastering advanced packaging geometries, warpage control, and fluid dynamics enables the next computational leap.